Free Standard Shipping on Orders $79+

Subscriptions Ship Free

Dog Treats That Are Bad for Dogs: Treats You Should Avoid

May 05, 2021 4 min read
five puppies eating from dog bowls

 

Unfortunately, not every dog treat is healthy for your dog. We love to spoil our pooch with a nice treat, yet some well-liked treats are silently packed with ingredients that are unhealthy for them. As a pet owner, knowing whichdog treats are actually 'bad' is the initial step towards making better choices for your dog.

Think of this as your crash course in healthy treating. We'll decode the deceptive labels, reveal whichtreats your dog should avoid, and empower you to make smart choices. With the knowledge of how to spot the junk and what a healthy serving size looks like, you can spoil your dog with confidence!

What Dog Treats Are Bad for Dogs? Common Ingredients to Watch Out For

What dog treats are worse for dogs? Start with the ingredients. Artificial preservatives like BHA, BHT, and ethoxyquin have been linked to health issues. Artificial colors serve no nutritional purpose and can cause a reaction in sensitive dogs. 

You need preservatives to keep dog treats and dog food fresh. However, not all preservatives are created equal. Artificial preservatives can be cheaper and keep food fresher for longer, but they can also contain harmful chemicals.

Some common artificial preservatives to look for on labels include butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA), butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT), propyl gallate, and ethoxyquin. BHA and BHT are two preservatives commonly found in dog and people food alike. According to Japanese research, these preservatives aren’t just keeping food fresh. Thestudy found that BHA and BHT are carcinogenic for animals like rats. BHA is also on the list of carcinogens, so it’s a good idea to avoid these harmful preservatives whenever possible.

Added sugars and excessive salt lead to weight problems and tooth issues. Poorly identified rendered fats on the labels can come from dubious sources. Be suspicious of generic terms like "meat by-product" or "animal digest." These are inferior ingredients that may contain parts of animals not intended for puppy consumption.

Look for treats that are made from real, recognizable ingredients like beef pizzle or duck breast. If you can easily identify what you're offering your dog, you're making a better treat choice.

Are Treats Bad for Dogs if They're High in Calories or Fillers?

Treats that are high in calories and full of fillers quickly add pounds and lead to upset stomachs. Commercial treats have corn, wheat, or soy as primary ingredients. These add bulk and little nutritional value, and dogs continue to feel hungry while gaining unnecessary calories.

High-protein, low-calorie treats like jerky or single-ingredient bully sticks provide satisfying chewing without empty calories. These dog chews keep dogs occupied while working to preserve muscle. Portion control is equally significant as ingredient quality in keeping your dog at their ideal weight.

What Treats Are Bad for Dogs with Allergies or Sensitivities?

Allergic dogs need special consideration. Foods with grains containing wheat, corn, or soy can trigger allergic reactions. Milk treats can be a cause of digestive upset for lactose-intolerant dogs, and artificially flavored treats contain allergens that are hard to identify.

For sensitive dogs, avoid artificial flavoring and gluten. Limited-ingredient and single-protein treats make it easier to pinpoint potential allergens if a reaction occurs. Simple beef or duck chews offersafer alternatives for sensitive stomachs.

Puppy teething is also a sensitive time for introducing new treats. Young dogs building their immune systems may be more prone to reactions, making single-ingredient options particularly valuable. 

Are All Dog Treats Bad for Dogs? Understanding the Real Issue

Are treats bad for dogs? Not by definition. The problem is actually low-quality treats with questionable ingredients and overindulgence. Mass-market treats are loaded with artificial preservatives, fillers, and additives that contribute to obesity and stomach problems.

Natural, single-ingredientchews like Best Bully Sticks are safer options. These treats encourage dental health and satisfy natural chewing urges without chemical preservatives. Moderation is key, as well as being conscious of what exactly goes into the treats you’re buying.

How Many Treats is Too Many?

Treats should never make up more than 10% of a dog's daily caloric requirement. Exceeding the recommendation leads to nutritional imbalance and obesity, which invites a host of joint problems and restricted mobility.

Even the healthiest dog treats are troublesome if overdone. Overfeeding leads to weight gain, nutritional imbalance, and a loss of appetite for regular meals. Some dogs start refusing their balanced diet after becoming too accustomed to treats.

Balance is key. Substitute praise, play, or affection as other rewards in addition to treats. This avoids overdependence on food rewards while solidifying your connection. If you do give treats, make portions suitable to your dog's size and activity level.

Being aware ofwhen to remove a bully stick ensures that there is no overindulgence and prevents your dog from exceeding daily calorie needs. What is healthy for dogs to consume in moderation becomes unhealthful if portion control is not practiced.

How to Read Dog Treat Labels Like a Pro

Label reading means you can quickly spot unhealthy dog treats and select healthier options. The first ingredient needs to be a real meat source like beef, chicken, or duck. Avoid foods with long, unpronounceable chemical-filled ingredient lists. Look for sourcing and manufacturing transparency. Responsible manufacturers display their country of origin and explain how they produce their foods. Lack or vague information should be a red flag for product quality and safety.

Single-ingredient chews offer ultimate transparency ... if a treat contains just one ingredient, you know exactly what you're feeding your pet without risking secret additives or suspicious fillers.

Choose Safe, Healthy Treats for a Happy Dog

Protecting your pup frombad treats for dogs starts with discerning selection. Avoid artificial ingredients and fillers, maintain small portion sizes, and choose natural treats composed of recognizable ingredients. Single-ingredient, high-proteintreats encourage healthier digestion, dental health, and overall well-being. By choosing wisely and feeding responsibly, you treat your dog safely while encouraging their long-term health and happiness.


Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in BBS Blog

dog with blue eyes chewing on antler
Bully Sticks vs Antler Chews: Which for Your Dog

February 25, 2026 4 min read

Take a look at the key differences between antlers and bully sticks. Learn which chew lasts longer, offers satisfaction, and benefits your dog.

Is a Best Bully Sticks Subscription Worth It?
Is a Best Bully Sticks Subscription Worth It?

February 25, 2026 3 min read

Wondering if you should take advantage of our subscription system? Read here to learn about how our subscription options can save you time and money!

dog sniffing hickory smoked dog chew
Why Do Dogs Love Smoked Chews?

January 28, 2026 3 min read

Why do dogs go absolutely crazy for a good smoked chew? It's not just about keeping them busy. These chews actually work double duty for your dog's health.

Product Title